You Are Not Your Worst Decision

One bad decision and suddenly everyone’s an expert on your character. What a load of shit. We’re selfish, compassionate, honest, dishonest, and occasionally complete assholes. Sometimes in the same week. Character isn’t a tattoo.. It’s a work in progress. And so are we.

Share
You Are Not Your Worst Decision

You Are Not Your Worst Decision

Character is a work in progress. So is understanding ourselves.

We love to tell people who they are.

Someone cheats on their spouse. They’re a cheater.

Someone lies. They’re a liar.

Someone makes a selfish decision. They’re selfish.

Someone loses their temper, says something cruel, or behaves in a way we find unacceptable. Suddenly, we’ve got their character all figured out.

Well, that was easy.

One incident. One decision. One chapter of someone’s life, and we’ve apparently collected enough evidence to deliver a permanent verdict on another human being.

I’d love to know when we all became such fucking experts.

Because I’ve been thinking about character lately. What it means, how we define it, and whether it’s nearly as permanent as we pretend it is.

And I’m beginning to think we’ve got quite a bit of it wrong.

Character Isn’t a Tattoo

We tend to describe character as though it’s something permanently etched into a person.

You’re either honest or dishonest. Faithful or unfaithful. Kind or cruel. Good or bad.

Pick your category. We’ll get you a name tag.

But I don’t think human beings work that way.

I think character is fluid.

Not necessarily in the sense that we become completely different people every morning, but in the way our behavior changes depending on circumstances, experiences, relationships, emotions, and the people around us.

Think about the person you were twenty years ago.

Hell, think about the person you were five years ago.

Have your beliefs changed? Your priorities? Your tolerance for bullshit? The things you’re willing to accept from other people?

Have you ever made a decision that seemed perfectly reasonable at the time but looks completely ridiculous in hindsight?

I certainly have.

And if we’re being remotely honest with ourselves, most of us have behaved in ways that contradict the values we claim to possess.

We’ve been generous and selfish. Compassionate and indifferent. Honest and deceptive. Patient and spectacularly unreasonable.

Sometimes in the same fucking week.

So which version is our actual character?

Or is the answer considerably more complicated?

And why do we insist on treating character as a finished product when we’re clearly still figuring out how to live?

The People Around Us Matter

I’ve always found it interesting how much our environments influence our behavior.

Spend enough time around angry people, and you might find yourself becoming angrier.

Surround yourself with people who constantly criticize others, and eventually you might start participating.

Find yourself in a relationship where communication has deteriorated, resentment has accumulated, and neither person feels particularly understood, and you may begin behaving in ways you wouldn’t recognize in another environment.

That doesn’t excuse harmful behavior.

But shouldn’t the circumstances matter when we’re trying to understand it?

People influence people.

We influence each other through our expectations, our behavior, our affection, our dishonesty, our generosity, and sometimes our complete inability to communicate like functioning adults.

And not all that influence is negative.

Sometimes you meet someone who makes you more comfortable being yourself. Someone who challenges your thinking without demanding that you agree. Someone whose company you genuinely enjoy.

You find yourself listening more. Laughing more. Being curious instead of defensive.

Does that mean your character suddenly improved?

Or were those qualities always there, waiting for circumstances where they could emerge?

I don’t fucking know.

But I think it’s worth considering before we decide we’ve figured someone out.

A Bad Decision Is Still a Bad Decision

Now, before anyone interprets this as an argument that nobody should be held accountable for anything, that’s not what I’m suggesting.

People make decisions. Those decisions have consequences.

An affair can devastate a marriage. A lie can destroy trust. Cruelty can leave someone carrying pain long after the person responsible has moved on.

We don’t get to erase those consequences simply because we’ve grown or because our intentions were complicated.

But there’s a difference between holding someone accountable for what they did and declaring that what they did represents the entirety of who they are.

And there’s another uncomfortable truth.

Relationships involve two human beings.

Both bring experiences, expectations, insecurities, communication habits, and personal histories into the arrangement.

That doesn’t mean both people share responsibility for every individual decision. The person who chooses to cheat owns that decision. The person who lies owns the lie.

But understanding why a relationship deteriorated requires more than identifying which person made the most visible mistake.

Sometimes the person who made the worst decision wasn’t the only person contributing to an unhealthy relationship.

Sometimes they were.

Sometimes we simply don’t have enough information to know.

Imagine that.

Not knowing.

What a concept.

Erich Fromm Had an Interesting Idea

I’ve been spending some time thinking about Erich Fromm and his book The Art of Loving.

One of his central arguments is that love isn’t merely a feeling we experience. It’s something we actively practice.

He identified care, responsibility, respect, and knowledge as essential elements of love.

I find that fascinating.

Because it moves the conversation away from what we claim to feel and toward what we actually do.

Anyone can tell another person they care.

Anyone can send a thoughtful text, make an emotional declaration, or promise they’ll always be there.

Words are relatively easy.

Actions require something else.

Consistency. Effort. Consideration. The willingness to listen when the conversation isn’t particularly enjoyable.

And sometimes the willingness to acknowledge that another person’s problems aren’t yours to solve.

Fromm’s understanding of responsibility is particularly interesting because he didn’t simply equate it with obligation. He understood it as a willingness to respond to another person’s needs.

Think about that.

You can recognize that someone is struggling without becoming responsible for fixing their life.

You can care about someone without possessing them.

You can respect another person’s independence while still choosing to be present.

And here’s the part I particularly appreciate.

You get to choose.

You aren’t obligated to enter someone else’s complicated world simply because they’ve shared their experiences with you.

You can listen. You can offer compassion. You can decide whether you want to participate in their life.

Or you can decide that you don’t.

That choice belongs to you, just as their choices belong to them.

And if two people freely choose to make room for each other, shouldn’t the way they treat one another matter more than the labels attached to their pasts?

We Confuse Character With Reputation

I think there’s another problem with how we judge people.

We often confuse character with reputation.

Reputation is what other people believe about us.

Character is more complicated. It’s reflected in our values, intentions, habits, and behavior. And those things don’t always align neatly.

Someone can enjoy an excellent reputation while behaving terribly in private.

Someone else can carry a horrible reputation because of something they did years ago, despite having spent considerable time changing how they live.

But reputations are convenient.

They save us the trouble of getting to know people.

It’s much easier to say someone is a bad person than to consider the possibility that a decent person made a destructive decision.

And it’s considerably easier to condemn someone else’s behavior than to examine our own.

Maybe that’s because recognizing the complexity of other people forces us to acknowledge something uncomfortable about ourselves.

Under different circumstances, with different influences and different emotional pressures, we might not always behave as admirably as we’d like to believe.

That’s not an excuse.

It’s a reason for a little humility.

Even Several Decisions Don’t Tell the Entire Story

Here’s where my thinking might become unpopular.

I don’t believe one event defines someone’s character.

I don’t necessarily believe several events do, either.

Patterns certainly matter. If someone repeatedly lies, manipulates, or hurts other people, those behaviors provide meaningful information about how they currently conduct themselves.

We would be foolish to ignore that.

But even patterns aren’t necessarily permanent.

People change. Sometimes for the better. Sometimes for the worse.

And sometimes they don’t change nearly as much as they claim.

Which is precisely why I place more value on actions than declarations.

Someone telling me they’ve changed is interesting.

Someone consistently behaving differently over time is considerably more convincing.

But even then, we’re observing a person at a particular point in their life.

Not delivering a final verdict on their entire existence.

I also think the way someone responds to their mistakes matters.

Do they acknowledge what happened?

Can they accept responsibility without constantly blaming someone else?

Are they willing to consider the consequences of their choices?

And perhaps most importantly, what do they do next?

Not what do they promise to do.

What do they actually do?

Forgiveness Isn’t a Get-Out-of-Jail-Free Card

There’s something else I’ve been considering.

Forgiving yourself.

I think people sometimes confuse self-forgiveness with excusing their behavior.

They’re not the same.

You can acknowledge that you hurt someone without spending the rest of your life punishing yourself.

You can regret a decision without allowing it to become your permanent identity.

You can accept that someone may never forgive you, and still decide to conduct yourself differently moving forward.

And here’s something that took me longer than I’d care to admit to understand.

You don’t get to demand forgiveness from the people you’ve hurt.

That’s their decision.

But you also don’t need their permission to continue growing as a human being.

Accountability and self-forgiveness can coexist.

In fact, I’d argue they probably should.

Otherwise, what exactly are we supposed to do?

Remain permanently defined by every regrettable decision we’ve ever made?

That sounds like a miserable fucking existence.

Self-Examination Is Never Finished

Here’s something else I’ve been thinking about.

We talk about personal growth as though there’s a finish line.

Like one day we’ll wake up, understand ourselves completely, have all our emotional baggage neatly organized, and finally become the enlightened human beings we were apparently supposed to be all along.

Congratulations. You’ve completed being a person.

What a load of shit.

I don’t believe self-examination ever really ends.

Our lives change. Our relationships change. The people around us influence us. Circumstances challenge beliefs we thought were firmly established.

Sometimes we learn something about ourselves that we’re proud of.

Other times we discover that we’re still capable of behaving like an asshole.

And sometimes we don’t recognize what we’re doing until considerably later.

That’s life.

I don’t think examining ourselves should mean endlessly dissecting every decision or turning every experience into some grand psychological revelation.

That sounds exhausting.

But being willing to occasionally ask ourselves uncomfortable questions?

I think there’s value in that.

Why did I react that way?

Was I being fair?

Did my actions reflect what I claim to believe?

Am I holding someone else to a standard I haven’t consistently met myself?

And perhaps the most difficult question:

Am I willing to change my mind about myself?

Because it’s easy to construct an identity around who we believe we are.

I’m honest. I’m loyal. I’m independent. I’m compassionate.

Wonderful.

But what happens when our behavior contradicts those beliefs?

Do we examine the contradiction?

Or do we immediately start explaining why this particular situation was different?

I know which option is easier.

And I know I’ve been guilty of choosing it.

Self-examination isn’t a guarantee that we’ll always behave better.

But refusing to examine ourselves seems like a pretty effective way to keep repeating the same mistakes.

Maybe Character Is Something We Keep Creating

I don’t think character is meaningless.

I don’t think people should be excused from responsibility because life is complicated.

And I certainly don’t think every person deserves unlimited opportunities to hurt the people around them.

Boundaries matter. Trust matters. Repeated behavior matters.

But I do think we need to reconsider the idea that character is something permanently established at a particular moment.

Maybe it’s better understood as something we’re continuously expressing, reinforcing, challenging, and occasionally contradicting through the choices we make.

Some of our values remain remarkably stable. Others evolve as we experience life.

And perhaps the important question isn’t whether someone has ever behaved badly.

It’s whether we’re willing to see them as more than that behavior while still taking seriously what they’ve done.

There’s room for compassion without abandoning judgment.

There’s room for understanding without making excuses.

And there’s room for someone to become a different version of themselves without pretending their previous decisions never happened.

I’ve been thinking more about what it means to live according to the values I claim to have.

Not because I’ve figured life out.

I haven’t.

But because I’ve realized that saying I believe in honesty, compassion, independence, or respect doesn’t mean much if those beliefs never make it into my behavior.

I want my actions to match my words.

I won’t always get that right.

Neither will anyone else.

And maybe that’s the point.

Character is always a work in progress. So is our understanding of ourselves.

We aren’t the same people we were twenty years ago. We won’t be exactly the same people twenty years from now.

At least I hope not.

There’s still an enormous amount to experience, question, reconsider, and occasionally fuck up.

And perhaps before we reduce someone to the worst thing we know about them, we should consider how little of their life we’ve actually witnessed.

While we’re at it, maybe we should examine how consistently our own behavior reflects the values we’re so quick to demand from everyone else.

I don’t fucking know.

But I’m willing to keep asking the questions.

And maybe that’s a decent place to start.

— Just James